For what was his fourteenth album, Johnny Mathis enlisted the help of noted conductor and arranger Nelson Riddle, whose previous credits included Frank Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald, Judy Garland and Peggy Lee. With Nelson's help, Johnny tackled material outside his normal boundaries, with I'll Buy You A Star featuring up tempo songs as well as the usual ballads. It would go on to be another winning formula, with the album making the Top 20 in the US.

1. I'll Buy You A Star
2. Stairway To The Stars
3. When My Sugar Walks Down The Street
4. Magic Garden
5. Smile
6. Oh How I Try
7. Ring The Bell
8. Love Look Away
9. Sudden Love
10. The Best Is Yet To Come
11. Warm And Willing
12. My Heart And I